[Op-Ed] Limits on Commercial Use of Student Records: Whose Admissions Information Ladder Has Narrowed?
-
Writer
Seong-jun Park
-
With the enforcement of the revised Elementary and Secondary Education Act last July, trading in or using school records for commercial purposes has been banned.
One can fully sympathize with the legislative intent of preventing the excessive commercialization of school records. But a noble purpose does not guarantee a good policy outcome.
In implementing this regulation, the government expected public education to absorb demand from the private college admissions market. In reality, however, things are unfolding in precisely the opposite direction.
Until now, students from provincial areas or lower-income families who had difficulty accessing the Daechi-dong cram school district had actively used school record analysis programs offered by major firms such as Megastudy and Jinhaksa. That was because, at a relatively low cost, they could receive objective analyses of their standing and admission chances using large-scale sample data. In other words, the online services of large firms were “the cheapest and most widely accessible ladder to admissions information.”
But as major firms halted school record-based admissions forecasting services because of this blanket regulation, students instantly lost an affordable and useful tool.
What is even more painful is the opportunity cost this regulation has overlooked.
With recent advances in AI technology, tools have emerged that can analyze vast amounts of admissions data at low cost, making it possible to commercialize forecasting services that are cheaper yet more sophisticated than existing online consulting. However, by blocking the commercial use of school record data itself, this regulation forced major platforms to suspend their services and ultimately cut off innovation that could reduce costs through technology. In effect, the regulation has turned against what could have been the most powerful tool for narrowing information and income gaps among students.
By contrast, offline consulting academies were able to sidestep the regulation with ease. Simply viewing school records may not fall under the regulatory ban, and consultants can also provide one-on-one counseling based solely on the experience they have accumulated over time.
As a result, provincial students who once had access to low-cost analysis are now more likely to have no choice but to travel to Seoul and rely on expensive in-person consulting.
The government has presented public consulting as an alternative, but it is far from sufficient to meet actual demand. In the case of the “Where Is College” college admissions information portal, the number of applicants is capped at no more than 250 per week, each student may use it only once a month, and it takes as long as two weeks to receive a response. These structural limitations are precisely why students and parents have long preferred private services over public ones.
Blanket regulation of the education market has always produced side effects. The ban on private tutoring in the 1980s did not eradicate private education; instead, it spawned underground “basement tutoring.” Likewise, the so-called “ban on 선행학습” proposed in 2014 failed to dampen the intense fervor for education.
When demand for education—something close to instinct—is suppressed only through regulation, a balloon effect emerges, and the more aggressively authorities crack down, the more overheated the underground market becomes. This vicious cycle repeats itself.
This regulation risks widening, rather than reducing, information gaps based on region and income. Families with financial resources and personal networks can still obtain information through individual counseling and other means, but provincial students and lower-income households have relatively few ways to replace online services.
If a regulation is meant to improve fairness, we must examine whose options it reduces first.
The indiscriminate circulation of school records is certainly undesirable. But any policy designed to prevent it must also take into account students’ access to information and the burden of cost.
Now is the time to coolly reflect on whether this regulation, hiding behind a noble cause while depriving students of even their minimal ladder to information, is pushing countless students and parents—already fighting a nerve-racking college admissions war—deeper into the quagmire of inequality.
Sungjoon Park, Intern Researcher, Center for Free Enterprise (CFE)
Original title: [칼럼] 생기부 상업 이용 제한, 누구의 입시 정보 사다리가 좁아졌나
Author: Seong-jun Park
Date: 2026-11-17
Source: https://www.cfe.org/bbs/bbsDetail.php?cid=free_opinion&pn=1&idx=29749
