Poor financial supervision and investors` devastation

곽은경 / 2020-10-22 / 조회: 12,132       The Korea Times

A series of fund redemption suspensions by private equity funds are disrupting the market. One notorious example is Lime Asset Management which saw losses of up to 1.6 trillion won ($1.3 billion).


Many investors, not only corporate investors but also individuals who invested a significant portion of their wealth, were hit hard. There are other cases of mis-selling and failures of private equity funds, such as Derivative-Linked Funds (DLFs), Discovery Fund and Optimus Fund, which have left many investors devastated.


Inevitably, the credit of the Korean financial market plunged. In the stream of disasters, and the very role and function of the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) has come into question.


The FSS is the authority in full control of financial businesses and the market itself in Korea. The FSS has a vast number of responsibilities, ranging from price and commission rates, to the very management of financial products released by each and every company onto the market. It is clear the FSS did not function properly considering recent events. In 2015, the financial authorities relaxed regulations on private equity funds with the intention of benefiting the market.


However, without any appropriate form of guidance or rules provided, fund management companies with little expertise came up with competitive high-risk products. The precautions taken were too cursory. The FSS betrayed honest players and consumers by allowing the entrance of a series of sloppy products onto the market. The FSS' irresponsibility cannot be overshadowed by the reckless actions of the corporations.


The actions taken by the FSS after the incidents were made public are also controversial, too. After the DLF crisis in 2019, the FSS banned banks and insurance companies from selling private equity funds and "trust goods." The FSS took this measure in response to the criticism that it failed to supervise corporations to ensure consumers fully understood the risks of investment. Interestingly enough, the FSS seems to have forgotten the fact that there were problems in terms of both sales and supervision.


Banning the sale of such products is a clear violation of the freedom of choice that consumers should be allowed to entertain. If the FSS was truly concerned about protecting investors, the actions taken should have been to ease the shock of incomplete sales and minimize mis-selling. Stopping the sale of products and goods in the market itself does not help to deliver the actual information that consumers deserve. This is just an inversion in the protection and promotion of consumers' rights.


The FSS ordered Lime Asset Management to fully compensate investors for its suspension of fund redemption. Full compensation is unprecedented. It seems like a political decision, as a response to the suspicion that political figures could be related to the issue. One cannot help but be reminded of the chronic dysfunction of government and politics intervening in the private financial sector. It has been the main factor dragging down the competitive edge of the Korean financial market and its corporations for a long time.


Investment encompasses not only profit but also the responsibility of having to bear risks and losses. It is clear that the management of the fund and sellers are to blame for failing to provide full and clear information to consumers. Nevertheless, investors who took high risks for higher returns should take their own fair share of responsibility.


To absolve investors from any sort of responsibility is purely political and populistic. Political influence affects the market negatively. Such decisions only trigger a moral hazard among investors and eventually result in the shrinking of the market. This is a loss for both the companies and investors. The market will be regulated from inventing and developing competitive financial products, which in turn can become a potential loss for future investors.


With Hong Kong losing its appeal as a financial hub in Asia, many foreign finance corporations are now moving to other countries. It is saddening to discover that Korea has been chosen by none. With strict regulations by the financial authorities, the freedom of enterprise is limited. Not to mention political influence lowering the efficiency of the financial market. Under such adverse circumstances, no policy to enhance competitiveness in finance is likely to emerge.


The FSS must provide clear and straightforward guidelines that befit the spirit of the free market for finance corporations to abide by. Consumers' rights and freedom of choice in the financial market can be well-protected and promoted in a market in which quality finance items compete with one another. Cutting off any possible liability by the means of regulation can never be the solution.


The profit and stability is proportionate to the competitiveness of financial companies. Activation of the financial market, and assurance of market stability can be achieved with clear lines of conduct and rules which will avoid hurting the freedom of the market itself. Now it is time for the FSS to take responsibility, not run away from it.



Kwack Eun-kyoung (rollypop55@gmail.com) is manager of economic policy department of Center for Free Enterprise (CFE).

       

▲ TOP

NO. 제 목 글쓴이 등록일자
279 노조의, 노조에 의한, 노조를 위한 국회
최승노 / 2023-11-20
최승노 2023-11-20
278 고금리 대출이자, 상생의 길을 찾아야
이헌석 / 2023-11-13
이헌석 2023-11-13
277 사회적기업·사회적기업진흥원의 역할 재정의가 시급하다
조한준 / 2023-11-09
조한준 2023-11-09
276 가족에 불이익 주는 규제와 세금, 해소해야
최승노 / 2023-11-08
최승노 2023-11-08
275 나이트의 불확실성(Knightian Uncertainty), 기업가정신, 그리고 골프
이웅희 / 2023-09-26
이웅희 2023-09-26
274 법치주의 훼손하는 노란봉투법
전삼현 / 2023-09-11
전삼현 2023-09-11
273 `국뽕`의 정치경제학
김성준 / 2023-09-04
김성준 2023-09-04
272 중소기업 지원 줄이고 대기업 규제 폐지해야
최승노 / 2023-08-20
최승노 2023-08-20
271 8·15 광복절 연설문에 담긴 `자유헌정론`의 메시지
최동용 / 2023-08-19
최동용 2023-08-19
270 내 집 마련과 처분에 따른 세금부담 줄여야
최승노 / 2023-08-18
최승노 2023-08-18
269 시장(市場)은 승자의 기록이다
조성봉 / 2023-08-10
조성봉 2023-08-10
268 기득권 철폐 외치던 586 운동권, 우리 사회 기득권으로 기생
원영섭 / 2023-08-09
원영섭 2023-08-09
267 일반 R&D 분야도 세액 공제 확대해야
황상현 / 2023-08-02
황상현 2023-08-02
266 타다금지법에 사라진 타다는 무죄···국회가 반성할 차례
김영훈 / 2023-07-26
김영훈 2023-07-26
265 [시장경제칼럼] 중대재해처벌을 개정해야 하는 중대한 이유
곽은경 / 2023-07-25
곽은경 2023-07-25